Filmsite Movie Review 100 Greatest Films
A Star Is Born (1954)
Pages: (1) (2)

A Star is Born is the superb 1954 dramatic musical and tearjerker, acclaimed by many as the greatest Hollywood musical ever made. Judy Garland's intense performance as the main character, probably the finest of her entire career, illuminated the film based upon Moss Hart's screenplay.

It was a superior remake of William Wellman's non-musical, classic 1937 film of the same name starring Janet Gaynor and Fredric March. [Note: It was also updated to modern times twice as a musical drama - first as the poorly-made A Star Is Born (1976) with Barbra Steisand as pop singer Esther Hoffman and Kris Kristofferson as rock star John Norman Howard, and second as A Star Is Born (2018), starring director/actor Bradley Cooper and Lady Gaga.]

The film's director, George Cukor, had also directed the film What Price Hollywood? (1932) that is considered the source of all three film versions. Cukor ironically commented upon Hollywood and how it only cared for its own by strategically positioning three official Hollywood ceremonies at the beginning, middle, and end of the film. Each one chronicled the downfall of a talented, but alcoholic Hollywood movie star (James Mason). [Note: Actors who rejected the role included Humphrey Bogart, Cary Grant (who accepted but then declined), Gary Cooper, Marlon Brando, and Montgomery Clift.]

The emotionally-intense psycho-drama also hinted at the real-life troubles and problems (five marriages) in the career of its female star - a victim of the Hollywood studio system - during the film's making. It was Garland's comeback and self-referential film (after she had been dismissed from her lead role in MGM's Annie Get Your Gun (1950) for health problems), and then suffered from alcoholic binges and suicide attempts. Garland's realistic performance reflected the upheavals in her own personal life that led to her death from a drug overdose - and ironically, this film's co-star James Mason delivered her funeral's eulogy in New York in 1969. Predicted to win the Best Actress Oscar, Garland was devastated by the loss to Grace Kelly in an lesser role in The Country Girl.

The film was both a disappointment at the box-office and at awards time. There were many unrewarded Academy Awards nominations - no Oscars for six nominations including: Best Actor (James Mason), Best Actress (Judy Garland), Best Color Art Direction/Set Decoration, Best Song ("The Man That Got Away", music by Harold Arlen, lyrics by Ira Gershwin), Best Scoring of a Musical Picture (Ray Heindorf), and Best Color Costume Design. And both director Cukor and screenplay author Moss Hart were neglected in the nominations.

The film, considered overlong at three hours, was drastically cut by Warners' film studio after its initial release. Painstaking restoration in the early 80s resulted in a revised, 170-minute version.

Plot Synopsis

(1) The "Night of Stars" Gala Benefit Event at Hollywood's Shrine Auditorium:

The film opens during the first of the three Hollywood ceremonies in the film, a gala benefit "Night of Stars," being held at Hollywood's Shrine Auditorium. The concert's proceeds will go to "The Motion Picture Relief Fund," a way to help out-of-work actors, as the Master of Ceremonies boasts: "Hollywood never forgets its own." Brilliant, but fading alcoholic movie actor Norman Maine (James Mason) arrives late to the benefit, obviously drunk. He staggers and wanders onto the stage in the middle of one of the acts. When one of the dancing performers, Esther Blodgett (Judy Garland) first notices him, seeing how drunk he is, she quips:

Mister Maine is feeling no pain.

Norman becomes belligerent backstage, particularly toward his pushy, mean-spirited studio publicist Matt Libby (Jack Carson), insulting him:

I don't need any more pictures, I don't need any more interviews, because the public loves me.

When Esther is performing in a song and dance act during a performance by the Glenn Williams Orchestra, Norman lurches onstage, making a drunken spectacle of himself in front of the audience. Still dancing and singing, cleverly incorporating him into her routine, she saves him from major embarrassment and leads him off the stage as the audience applauds.

Norman's Acquaintance with Singer/Dancer Esther Blodgett:

After the performance, Maine realizes the extraordinary gesture she has made and thanks her. Learning her name, he comments:

You must have been born with that name. You couldn't have made it up.

Still inebriated, on one of the backstage walls, he draws a heart with an arrow through it and their initials, using her lipstick. Norman asks Esther to dinner, but her pianist, Danny McGuire (Tommy Noonan) rescues her. Maine threatens meanness:

I know myself extremely well. I'm just near the fighting stage at the moment, and if I don't get my way, I begin to break up people and things.

To mollify him, she promises to see him sometime later, and as she leaves, she reveals a true liking for him:

You know, drunk or not, he's nice.

A sullen Libby takes Norman safely home to sleep off his drunkenness. In the middle of the night, haunted by the memory of Esther, he awakens and determines to track her down. He first goes to the Ambassador Hotel's Cocoanut Grove, thinking she might be there. A well-known, frequent womanizer, Norman discusses and rates potential pickups and conquests with the maitre-d: "Too young. I had a very young week last week. It's not worth it." It is suggested that he might locate Esther at an empty, after-hours Sunset Strip musicians' hangout, the Downbeat Club.

At the Sunset Strip Club - Late Night Ballad: "The Man That Got Away"

When he enters the club, he is transfixed as he watches her sing the torch song blues/ballad classic, "The Man That Got Away," a memorable performance to a room filled with stacked chairs.

Esther is surprised to see him there, and sober too! He compliments her, finding a tremendous 'jolt of pleasure' in her unique singing style:

There are certain pleasures you get, little - little jabs of pleasure when, when a swordfish takes the hook or - or - or when you watch a great fighter getting ready for the kill, see?

He tells her she is a great singer just waiting to be discovered. He is impressed by her star quality and spark of genius:

You've got that little something extra that Ellen Terry talked about. Ellen Terry, a great actress long before you were born. She said that that was what star quality was - that little something extra. Well, you've got it.

Norman's Encouraging Words to Esther About Her Future Song/Stage Career:

Norman tells her she is wasting her time singing with a small band. While driving her home, he asks what she is thinking, and they end up discussing their idiosyncrasies with each other:

Esther: Do you know the only thing I can think of right now? The only thought that comes into my mind is the way I wash my hair. You see, when anything happens to me good or bad, I make straight for the shampoo bottle. Why would I have to think of that now?
Norman: I understand that perfectly. With me, it's golf balls. If I'm happy or if I'm miserable, I - I putt golf balls around the living room. It makes perfect sense.

She tells him about her life story:

I can remember my first job singing with the band. And then one night stands clear across country by bus. Putting on nail polish in the ladies rooms of gas stations, waiting on tables. Wow! That was a low point. I'll never forget it. And I'll never never do that again, no matter what. But I had to sing. I somehow feel most alive when I'm singing.

They arrive at her furnished singles place, and she invites him in to look at her scrapbook. After divulging everything about herself, Esther asks Norman:

Have you had enough, as the Republicans used to say?...You know about as much about me now as I do about myself.

Esther dreams of having a lucky break, being discovered by a record company talent scout and having a number one hit song. But she expresses pessimism: "...It won't happen." But Norman has great confidence: "No, it might happen very easily. Only the dream isn't big enough." He again asks her to give up her small-time band for a chance at a movie career. He advises her:

Listen to me, Esther, a career is a curious thing. Talent isn't always enough. You need a sense of timing - an eye for seeing the turning point or recognizing the big chance when it comes along and grabbing it. A career can rest on a trifle. Like - like us sitting here tonight. Or it can turn on somebody saying to you, 'You're better than that. You're better than you know.' Don't settle for the little dream. Go on to the big one...Scared? Scared to take the plunge?

He gives her some final words of encouragement before he leaves: "Don't ever forget how good you are. And hang on to that. Because I'm right." And then, he delivers his trademark farewell words to her, repeated later in the film: "I just want to take another look at you."

Too excited to sleep, she goes upstairs to tell her pianist Danny that she is not going to Frisco with the band the next morning. "Norman Maine is going to get me a screen test." Danny can't believe her, accusing Maine of making a 'conventional pass.' But Esther will not be swayed:

He gave me a look at myself I've never had before. He saw something in me nobody else ever did. He made me see it too. He made me believe it.

She is determined "for a chance at being something, something bigger than I ever dreamed of. And I'm not going to turn back now, ever." Danny thinks she is a fool.

The next day, Norman leaves town for six weeks, shooting a new film in a distant locale. He can't recall her address. Meanwhile, Vicki has left her band and become unemployed. In the meantime, she has provided the singing voice for television commercials and worked as a carhop in a hamburger drive-in.

Esther's Screen Test and Promotion as Vicki Lester:

Hearing her voice singing a commercial on TV, he finally locates her. He sponsors her entry into show business, recommending her for a screen test. She passes the test and is hired as a contract bit player at the Oliver Niles Movie Studio (Norman's studio), although she is treated as another one of Maine's conquests. Norman intervenes and refuses to have her look changed - with a blonde wig and nose prosthetic, and restores her previous appearance. She is shuttled through the studio, passed from one person to another, greeted cordially but impersonally: "Glad to have you with us."

In Vicki's first minor acting role, she is yelled at by the director for not following his directions in a farewell scene: "I don't want to see your face, see." By the end of the week, she is renamed Vicki Lester - she learns of her new screen name when she receives her first paycheck. Then, Maine is able to cajole the reluctant studio head Oliver Niles (Charles Bickford) to listen to Vicki sing and she gets her big break. She is put in the lead singing role of a musical comedy when another singer cancels out of her contract.

The Film's Major Production Number: "Born in a Trunk"

In this lead film role, seen in the film's preview screening (a 'movie within a movie'), at a special showing in which Norman's new film Another Dawn is also being previewed, she performs a classic, 18-minute sequence. It is one of the finest and most distinctive musical film sequences ever made, opening and closing with "Born in a Trunk." It is presented as Esther's career success story in the form of an exquisitely-staged musical "biography" of her character beginning with her family's vaudeville performance as one of 'The 3 McCoys', and her rise to stardom as Vicki Lester. (It is also a near-autobiographical account of actress Judy Garland's own show business career). She comments on being a "ten-year-overnight sensation," singing a medley of such classics as:

  • "I'll Get By (As Long as I Have You)"
  • "You Took Advantage of Me"
  • "Black Bottom"
  • "My Melancholy Baby"
  • "Swanee" (in a minstrel-like performance, wearing a man's hat and suit)

Vicki's film preview debut is a sensational success, compared to the lukewarm reception that Norman's film receives, as the studio's publicity director Matt Libby brags: ("Say, I've never seen preview cards like this in my life. I waited for the breakdown. Ninety-seven percent say you got yourself a new star").

Norman's Doubts About His Own Fading Career:

Norman begins to experience mixed feelings about his protege, sensing that her burgeoning film and musical career will leave him far behind:

It's all yours, Esther. And I don't mean just the Cadillacs and the swimming pools. It's all yours, in more ways than one...You're going to be a great star, Esther. Don't let that change you too much. Don't let it take over your life. You're very dear.

She senses his awareness that he destroys everything to which he gets close, and wants to get out of their relationship:

Vicki: Norman, you make this sound like the end of something instead of the beginning. You make it sound like goodbye.
Norman: I've done all I can for you. You've come along the road with me as far as you should. Let's leave it that way.
Vicki: Norman, don't you know how I feel about you?
Norman: Yes, yes I do.
Vicki: Well, then dear, don't you know that nothing about you could make any difference?
Norman (despairing and warning her): It's too late.
Vicki: No, it isn't. It is not ---
Norman: It is, I tell you.
Vicki: Norman, there's nothing you can...
Norman: Now listen to me.
Vicki: I love you. I will not -
Norman: I destroy everything I touch. I always have. Forget me. I'm a bad lot. You've come too late.
Vicki: I don't believe that. It's not too late. Not for you, not for me.
Norman: Don't say that, Esther. I might begin to believe it.
Vicki: Please, believe it. Believe it. Believe it. Believe it.

Esther wants him to believe that it is not too late and that they should give themselves a try.

Next Page